Can You Take Legal Action Against a Negative Review?
Yes—if it crosses the line from opinion to defamation, false claims, or privacy violations.
While most negative reviews are protected as free speech, some go too far. If a review contains false statements, personal attacks, or misleading claims, you may have strong legal grounds to challenge it.
Here’s how to take action when a negative review is legally out of bounds.
Dig Deeper: How to Delete a Google Review
When a Negative Review Crosses the Line
Not all bad reviews are worth a legal fight. To challenge a review on legal grounds, it must fall into one of these categories:
1. Defamation (Libel)
A review becomes defamatory when it makes false statements of fact that damage your reputation.
Examples:
- “This business is under investigation for fraud.” (If it’s not true)
- “They stole my credit card information.” (Without proof)
2. Privacy Violations
If a review exposes your personal information without consent, it may violate privacy laws.
Examples:
- Posting your home address, phone number, or email.
- Sharing private medical, financial, or legal information.
3. Harassment or Threats
If a review includes direct threats, personal attacks, or ongoing harassment, it may qualify for legal action.
Examples:
- “I hope this business burns down.”
- Using racial slurs, hate speech, or bullying language.
4. False Criminal Claims
Accusing you or your business of a crime you didn’t commit can be both defamatory and legally actionable.
Examples:
- “They scammed me.” (If you have proof it didn’t happen)
- “They sold me illegal products.” (Without evidence)
5. Reviews from Competitors or Ex-Employees
If you can prove the reviewer is a competitor, ex-employee, or someone with a clear conflict of interest, you may have legal leverage.
Step 1: Collect Evidence
Before taking any legal action, you need clear proof that the review is false, misleading, or illegal.
What to Collect:
- Screenshots of the Review: Include the reviewer’s name, profile, and date.
- Business Records: Prove the reviewer never used your service or bought from you.
- Communication History: If the reviewer is an ex-employee, competitor, or someone with a known conflict.
- Supporting Documents: Invoices, contracts, customer records, or third-party witness statements.
Pro Tip:
Save a copy of the review quickly—some reviewers delete their posts when threatened with legal action.
Step 2: Request Correction or Removal (Directly)
If the reviewer is a real customer, you can try resolving the issue directly.
How to Request Removal:
- Contact the reviewer politely (if you know them).
- Acknowledge their feedback, but clarify any false information.
- Ask if they are willing to update or delete the review.
Example Message:
“Hi [Reviewer’s Name], I noticed your review and wanted to clarify that [false statement] isn’t accurate. I’d be happy to discuss this further and address any concerns you have. Would you consider updating your review to reflect our discussion?”
If they refuse or become hostile, stop contacting them and move to the next step.
Step 3: Report the Review to the Platform
If the review violates the platform’s content policies, you can request removal:
- Google: Use the Google Reviews Management Tool.
- Yelp: Click the three-dot menu on the review and select “Report Review.”
- Facebook: Go to the review and select “Find Support or Report Recommendation.”
When Reporting Works Best:
- The review is clearly false.
- It includes private information or threats.
- It comes from a competitor or fake profile.
Step 4: Send a Cease and Desist Letter
If the platform refuses to remove the review, and the reviewer won’t cooperate, a cease and desist letter is your next move.
How to Write a Cease and Desist:
- Use a formal letter format.
- Clearly identify the false statements.
- Explain how the review is damaging your reputation.
- Demand that the reviewer delete or correct the review.
- Set a deadline for compliance (usually 7-14 days).
- Have it sent by a lawyer for added weight.
Example:
Dear [Reviewer’s Name],
This letter serves as a formal demand that you immediately cease making false and defamatory statements about [Your Business] on [Platform]. Your review, posted on [Date], contains false claims that are damaging to our reputation.
Specifically, your statement that “[False Claim]” is untrue and has caused measurable harm to our business.
We demand that you delete this review within 7 days. If you fail to comply, we reserve the right to take further legal action.
Sincerely,
[Your Name / Attorney’s Name]
[Contact Information]
Step 5: File a Defamation Lawsuit
If the cease and desist letter doesn’t work, and the damage is serious, you can file a defamation lawsuit.
What You Need:
- Proof that the review is false.
- Evidence of financial or reputational damage caused by the review.
- Legal representation from an experienced attorney.
Possible Outcomes:
- A court order requiring the review to be deleted.
- Monetary damages for lost income or harm to your reputation.
- An official statement clearing your name.
When This Is Worth It:
- The review accuses you of a crime or unethical behaviour.
- The reviewer has ignored all other requests to correct it.
- The financial or reputational damage is significant.
Step 6: Use Google’s Legal Removal Tools
If the review is still visible in search, you can request deindexing using Google’s legal tools:
- For Defamation: Google Legal Removal Form
- For Privacy Violations: (if it reveals your personal information)
- For Copyright Issues: (if it uses your content or images without permission)
This removes the review from search results, even if the platform refuses to delete it.
Legal Action Is a Last Resort
Challenging a negative review on legal grounds is serious—and should only be used when the review is false, damaging, and refuses to be resolved any other way.
But if your reputation is at stake, don’t hesitate to protect it.
Need Help Removing False or Defamatory Reviews?
At Reputation Galaxy, we help businesses remove false reviews, suppress damaging content, and protect their online image—even when legal action is needed.
No win, no fee. Private support. Proven results.
Get a Free Quote or call us now to start protecting your name.